News

What Does It Mean to Be a Jew?

Ask this question today and you will likely receive many different answers.

Some will say Judaism is a religion.

Others will say it is a culture, an ethnicity, a nationality, a civilization, a family history, or a shared collective memory.

For some, Jewish identity is expressed through holidays and traditions. For others, it is connected to language, food, politics, social values, or support for a particular vision of Jewish life.

All of these answers contain elements of truth.

Yet they also point to a deeper reality: modern Jews often struggle to agree on what fundamentally defines Jewish identity.

This raises an important question.

If every Jew defines Jewishness differently, what ultimately holds us together?

What transforms millions of individuals, scattered across continents and generations, into a single people?

To answer that question, we must travel back to the beginning.

Before There Was a Jewish Nation

The Jewish people did not begin with a state.

We did not begin with borders, political institutions, armies, passports, or national symbols.

Long before there was a Jewish kingdom, there was a covenant.

At Mount Sinai, the descendants of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob entered into a covenant with God and accepted the Torah.

This moment became the defining event in Jewish history.

The Torah was not simply a religious text. It provided a framework for understanding life itself. It spoke about justice and compassion, family and community, holiness and responsibility. It established a shared mission and a shared purpose.

The covenant created a people.

The land came afterward.

This distinction is important.

Most nations are primarily connected by geography, language, or political institutions.

The Jewish people were connected by something different: a shared relationship with God and a shared commitment to a way of life.

The Torah became the foundation upon which Jewish identity was built.

The Land and the Covenant

The Land of Israel occupies a central place in Jewish history.

Yet according to the Torah itself, possession of the land was never unconditional.

The covenant carried both blessings and responsibilities.

The prophets repeatedly warned that abandoning the values and obligations of the covenant would carry consequences.

Eventually, Jewish history unfolded exactly as those warnings described.

The destruction of the First Temple led to exile.

Centuries later, the destruction of the Second Temple brought another exile.

The Jewish people lost political sovereignty over their homeland.

What they did not lose was their identity.

How the Jewish People Survived

This is one of history's great mysteries.

Empires disappeared.

Languages vanished.

Entire civilizations faded into memory.

Yet the Jewish people endured.

How?

Because while the land was lost, the covenant remained.

Jews carried their identity wherever they went.

In prayer.

In study.

In family life.

In community.

In shared beliefs and practices.

Across North Africa, the Middle East, Europe, Central Asia, and beyond, Jewish communities preserved a common framework even while developing local customs and traditions.

They often found themselves living among societies whose beliefs differed dramatically from their own.

At times they experienced acceptance.

At other times they faced discrimination, persecution, expulsion, or violence.

Yet despite these pressures, generation after generation chose continuity.

Not because it was easy.

Because they believed what they carried was worth preserving.

The World Changes

Then came the Enlightenment.

Beginning in Europe during the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, the Enlightenment transformed the Western world.

Reason increasingly replaced tradition as the highest authority.

Individual freedom became a central value.

Scientific inquiry flourished.

Political equality expanded.

New possibilities emerged for groups that had long existed on the margins of society.

For Jews, the Enlightenment represented both opportunity and challenge.

For centuries, Jewish communities had remained distinct partly because outside societies kept them distinct.

Now many barriers were beginning to fall.

Jews could attend universities.

Enter professions previously closed to them.

Participate in broader society.

Become citizens rather than outsiders.

This was an extraordinary development.

But it also raised a question previous generations rarely had the luxury of asking:

What parts of Jewish identity should remain, and what parts should change?

New Ways of Being Jewish

Different Jews answered this question differently.

Some sought to balance tradition with modern life.

Others concluded that traditional Jewish practice was no longer relevant.

Some viewed Judaism primarily as a religion.

Others saw it as a culture.

Some embraced nationalism.

Others embraced universalism.

Some maintained traditional observance.

Others moved away from it entirely.

New religious movements emerged.

New political movements emerged.

New definitions of Jewish identity emerged.

The Jewish world became increasingly diverse.

The diversity itself was not the problem.

The challenge was that Jews increasingly disagreed about the foundation upon which Jewish identity rested.

For centuries, Torah had provided a common framework.

Now competing frameworks emerged alongside it.

The result is a conversation that continues to this day.

The Fragmentation of Identity

Modern Jews inherited freedoms previous generations could scarcely imagine.

Yet freedom often comes with new forms of uncertainty.

Today, many Jews feel connected to certain aspects of Jewish life while disconnected from others.

Some connect through history.

Some through culture.

Some through family.

Some through politics.

Some through spirituality.

Some through the State of Israel.

Some through social justice.

Some through religious practice.

Many combine elements from several of these categories.

This diversity reflects the complexity of modern Jewish life.

Yet it also raises an important question.

What happens when a people no longer shares a common understanding of what fundamentally defines them?

Imagine a large banquet.

Everyone walks through the buffet line selecting what they wish to place on their plate.

A little of this.

A little of that.

Definitely not that.

When everyone sits down, some plates look remarkably similar.

Others share almost nothing in common.

What unites the people at the table?

Not necessarily what is on the plate.

The plate itself.

The challenge facing modern Jewish identity is similar.

When each person selects different aspects of Jewish life to embrace and different aspects to discard, what remains as the common foundation?

What is the plate?

For most of Jewish history, the answer was clear.

The Torah.

Defining Ourselves

For much of Jewish history, Jews were not afforded the luxury of defining themselves.

Kings defined us.

Empires defined us.

Churches defined us.

Political movements defined us.

Our enemies defined us.

Again and again, Jews found themselves viewed through the lens of others.

Sometimes we were accused of being too different.

Other times we were accused of not being different enough.

We were portrayed as outsiders, insiders, capitalists, revolutionaries, nationalists, cosmopolitans, believers, unbelievers, and countless other contradictory things.

The details changed from century to century.

The experience remained remarkably consistent.

When a people spend enough time being defined by others, they can eventually begin seeing themselves through those same borrowed lenses.

Much of modern Jewish discourse still revolves around responding to how others describe us, criticize us, misunderstand us, or seek to redefine us.

Yet perhaps the more important question is not how others define the Jewish people.

The more important question is how Jews define themselves.

What remains essential regardless of political affiliation?

What remains essential regardless of geography?

What remains essential regardless of changing cultural trends?

What values, beliefs, responsibilities, and commitments remain integral to Jewish identity?

These are not merely academic questions.

They are the questions every generation must wrestle with.

The future of Jewish identity will not be secured simply by responding to the definitions imposed upon us by others.

It will be secured when Jews once again engage in the timeless work of defining themselves from within the framework of their own history, their own covenant, and their own values.

The Search of Our Generation

The challenge facing Jews today is not to recreate the past.

History cannot be rewound.

Nor should it be.

Every generation faces unique circumstances and unique opportunities.

The challenge is to understand what is worth carrying forward.

Many Jews today feel a hunger for something deeper than labels.

A hunger for meaning.

For belonging.

For continuity.

For purpose.

This is not a sign of weakness.

It is a sign that the search continues.

The search for Jewish identity is ultimately the search for understanding.

Who are we?

What do we stand for?

What responsibilities accompany our inheritance?

What values deserve to be preserved?

What kind of future are we building for the generations that follow us?

These questions cannot be answered by politics alone.

Nor by culture alone.

Nor by history alone.

They require study.

Reflection.

Conversation.

And a willingness to revisit the sources from which Jewish identity originally emerged.

Returning to the Source

Returning to Torah does not mean withdrawing from the modern world.

It means reconnecting with the source that gave birth to Jewish identity in the first place.

For thousands of years, Torah provided Jews with a shared language for understanding purpose, morality, responsibility, community, and the relationship between man and God.

It served as an anchor through periods of exile, uncertainty, prosperity, and hardship.

The question before our generation is not whether we can recreate the world of our ancestors.

The question is whether we can recover the wisdom that allowed them to carry Jewish identity across centuries and continents without losing themselves.

A Living Conversation

The search for authentic Jewish identity is not about returning to a particular century.

It is not about recreating the past.

It is about reconnecting with the enduring principles that allowed the Jewish people to remain a distinct people through exile, dispersion, prosperity, hardship, and change.

Every generation inherits the responsibility of asking:

What does it mean to be a Jew?

What do we stand for?

What values are essential?

What are we willing to preserve and pass forward?

These questions are not answered in a single article, nor by any one individual.

They are part of an ongoing conversation that stretches across generations.

Throughout history, Jews carried this identity not only through ideas and beliefs, but also through symbols that reminded them of who they were and where they came from.

One of those symbols was the Sudra.

Mentioned throughout the Talmud and once common throughout Jewish life, the Sudra served as a practical garment, a marker of dignity, and a quiet reminder of a people's shared heritage.

Today, most Jews have never heard of it.

How did such a familiar Jewish garment become largely forgotten?

What can its history teach us about memory, continuity, and identity?

And why are increasing numbers of Jews rediscovering it today?

In our next article, we will explore the history of the Sudra and what this ancient Jewish garment can still teach us about who we are—and who we may yet become.